We recently published our practical guide to CASL compliance for email marketers. In this post we’ll look a bit closer at an important aspect of CASL compliance: how to properly obtain express consent in your email signup forms. We also recommend that you review these guidelines on the same topic, published directly by Canadian Radio-Television and Telecommunications Commission.

What information needs to be displayed on the form

CASL requires that specific information be provided on a signup form to obtain express consent. Specifically, an opt-in form:

  • Must clearly indicate what you are asking recipients to opt into.
  • Must indicate who is the sender.
  • Must include mailing address AND phone, email, or Web address of the parties seeking consent.
  • Must indicate that the recipient may unsubscribe.

Here is an example of a form that does not properly collect express consent, as it fails to include enough information on what will be sent, does not include contact information, and there is no indication that the recipient may unsubscribe.

Form not CASL compliant

Here is the same form, but with added information for CASL compliance. It contains clear details on what will be sent, instructions on how to unsubscribe, and contact information for the company that will be sending the newsletter.

CASL compliance email subscription form

There are cases in which consent to send commercial emails is collected as part of a form whose main purpose is something else. For example a checkout page on an e-commerce store, or a free trial signup form, as shown in the example below.

The first picture shows a non-compliant form: the main issue is that the checkbox through which consent is collected is pre-checked. Remember that CASL is an opt-in law, not an opt-out one. So customers must opt-in. Additionally, the form fails to include the other information that must be provided.

CASL not compliant form

Here is a compliant version of the same form:

  • It contains a link to the privacy policy for more information
  • It provides information about unsubscribing
  • The opt-in checkbox is not checked

Free trial form CASL compliant

Note that if the signup form is part of a Web page that contains detailed contact information, but not directly within the signup form itself (e.g. a checkout page on an online store), that should be sufficient (make sure that it is clear that the sender is the company whose contact information is displayed elsewhere on the same page).

Signup forms and double opt-in

If editing a form is difficult or impossible, we believe that using a double opt-in (or “confirmed opt-in”) email subscription method may satisfy CASL requirements as consent is given in the subscription confirmation request email. This opinion is based on the fact that the subscriber remains “pending” (not a subscriber yet!) until subscription is confirmed (i.e. until consent is given) by clicking on the corresponding link in the subscription confirmation request message. Please note that this is our opinion, not legal advice. You should check your specific scenario with your lawyer.

More details on this in our practical guide to CASL compliance.

Liked this article? We have plenty more in store for you.

Subscribe to get news, tips and updates delivered to your inbox.

Read also

Email marketing and typography: tips on formatting and style

How much does sending campaigns with readable, impactful text really matter? Time to rethink text style and formatting. Much of the recent typography discussion in Email ...

Read more

Email marketing & e-commerce: a research on the Covid-19 impact

We have combined the results of two researches: one by MailUp and the other by B2c eCommerce Observatory from the Polytechnic University of Milan's School ...

Read more

Email Design: 4 Tips for Header Design

From logo best practices, to the use of color, to skillfully combining consistency and variety. The header is the first thing a recipient sees in an ...

Read more

6 Email Marketing Tips For Brick And Mortar Businesses

Email marketing can be game-changing for attracting and retaining customers. In fact, when executed successfully, email marketing has the potential of receiving a 4400% ROI; ...

Read more

UX Design and SEO synergy boosts site traffic

Let's check out 8 key actions in designing a user experience that also benefits search engine positioning. A decade ago, SEO rankings were the sole company ...

Read more

Why You Need To Nail Your Visuals In Email Marketing

The perfect marketing email comprises many elements: flawless copy, coordinated sequences, compelling subject lines, valuable content. But one of the most crucial elements — arguably ...

Read more