5 min.

Certainly, the engagement of some emails could improve dramatically these days. However, at the same time, a wrong message could damage both the branding and reputation of sending.

One of the main activities of the Deliverability team during this period, is to monitor the delivery and performance of MailUp customers in real-time to ensure that important messages are delivered promptly and smoothly.

Brands tend to yield to their urge to communicate with all their recipients in these circumstances. This leads them to also include those contacts usually excluded from mailing.

Clearly, it’s the crisis that pushes companies to break with good email marketing practices, such as segmentation, monitoring, testing, and balancing the distribution of mailings over time to avoid sudden volume peaks.

A recent example

A few charts can offer a better idea of what’s going on these days. Here’s a customer who found himself forced to quintuple the number of emails sent in a day, bringing it to almost 3 million.  All inactive contacts on the list were also included.

A massive sending activity like this surely has repercussions in terms of deliverability. Unfortunately, the algorithms of the provider’s spam filtering systems are unforgiving.

Lessons from best practices

In a recent article, Gartner highlighted best practices to follow in this historical situation. The post discouraged sending communication before considering the following:

  • Are you about to communicate something different than other brands?
  • Does your email content diverge from what recipients are used to receiving?
  • Can recipients grasp the key information of your communication from the subject and first email lines?
  • Does key email information relate to the recipients’ needs at this specific time? Gartner emphasizes the latter.

Actions during the emergency weeks

Given the critical situation, the general rule of thumb should be to reduce clogging emails and general background noise as much as possible. This will favor and give greater visibility to updates and communications that are rather important.

More specifically, here are my recommendations and those of the MailUp Deliverability team:

  1. Before emailing, verify that the above indications are met, answering: “do recipients really need to receive this communication?
  2. DO NOT take advantage of the moment to update your database with a significant amount of new contacts that have never been mailed before. Very old or incorrectly acquired contacts can lead to a decline in reputation or even blacklisting, not to mention this could generate a peak of unsubscribers. This would jeopardize your database, even once the emergency is over.
  3. If you’d like to sell something or launch special promotions right now, then I strongly recommend you think again. This could be seen as a misplaced initiative and shed a bad light on you.

A final reflection on engagement

Having set these necessary premises, let me share a lateral thought developed by analyzing the patterns of different customers, particularly the outliers of this period.

The experience of these weeks teaches us that email is not just marketing. In fact, it can be the most effective tool for communicating in times of need.

However, we also learn that the average results we’re used to considering as standard may very well not be so these days. The open rates, the clicks, and even the ROI (in the most general sense of the term, i.e. the return of a certain activity) can change depending on the context.

We know how the activities of the recipients on the email are proportional to the relevance of the content conveyed. The chart below shows a customer’s OR and CR rate. Compared to an average of 20% OR and 4% CR, an important message related to the coronavirus emergency pushed the opening rate to almost 40% (double) and the click rate to 15% (+73 %).

Generally speaking, I noticed that the number of emails sent increased by circa 10% but, in my opinion, this isn’t necessarily significant. Rather, what’s significant is that it’s possible to isolate a cluster of customers who’ve had a very high increase (from 200 to 400%) in terms of engagement. These belong to different sectors, such as retail, healthcare, universities, municipal administrations, etc.

All the companies in this cluster share one element: the content is very relevant for the recipients and more relevant than the content they were used to receiving from the same customers.

In summary

Although there’s no a lot of room for positive thoughts in the broader context, we’re glad to find that even in difficult times, email recipients react energetically. 

This post has aimed to emphasize that if we are, in fact, seeing a marked improvement in the engagement of some communication compared to the average, then it’s equally true that a wrong message or practice could worsen the branding and sending reputation compared to the past.

Let’s not panic nor consider this period as the most favorable to contact even those recipients that we’ve excluded from our mailings for months or years. Better, let’s email them too, only if we have something fundamental to communicate or something out of the ordinary.

Always think in terms of relevance: even here, this is always the best parameter for having positive responses from the recipients.

Thank you!

Liked this article? We have plenty more in store for you.

Subscribe to get news, tips and updates delivered to your inbox.

Read also

How a sender’s domain reputation affects deliverability

One out of five marketing emails does not reach the recipient's inbox (Return Path). A leading cause is the sender's reputation. Let's see which factors ...

Read more

Mobile-friendly, responsive, and hybrid-design emails: here are the differences

Email Marketing evolved by embracing many changes; especially the beginning of the mobile era. Several approaches have been developed in order to answer to new ...

Read more

Marketing psychology: improve your email design by exploiting how your customers’ minds work

Today in 2020, emails are still one of the most effective marketing channels, but when it comes to designing an email that converts, a large ...

Read more

UX design: how to design user experiences for email marketing

Turning an email in a pleasant and memorable experience is the aim of any marketer who wants to increase his/her conversions. Here are some usefule ...

Read more

Email marketing and typography: tips on formatting and style

How much does sending campaigns with readable, impactful text really matter? Time to rethink text style and formatting. Much of the recent typography discussion in Email ...

Read more

Email marketing & e-commerce: a research on the Covid-19 impact

We have combined the results of two researches: one by MailUp and the other by B2c eCommerce Observatory from the Polytechnic University of Milan's School ...

Read more